Item #6273 [Archive of Amos Osborne Squire, Medical Examiner for Westchester County, New York, and Former Chief Physician at Sing Sing Prison]. Medicine, Prison.

[Archive of Amos Osborne Squire, Medical Examiner for Westchester County, New York, and Former Chief Physician at Sing Sing Prison]

[Various locations: 1928-1936]. Twenty-nine letters and documents, totaling [36]pp., plus a 10pp. manuscript and additional related photos, ephemera, and clippings. A few items dated later or earlier. Old folds, some light wear and scattered soiling. Very good. Item #6273

An interesting archive of items relating to the career of Amos Osborne Squire, the Chief Physician at Sing Sing Prison in the 1920s and the medical examiner for Westchester County for nearly twenty-five years.  Squire (1876-1949) was a graduate of the Columbia College of Physicians and Surgeons in 1899, subsequently establishing his medical practice in Ossining. He ran a private sanitarium from 1910 to 1920, and was appointed chief physician at Sing Sing prison in 1914. Though opposed to capital punishment, he held this post for ten years before deciding it was too emotionally taxing. He served as the medical examiner for the county from 1925 until his death in 1949. He published a book about his experiences at Sing Sing in 1935.

The centerpiece of the present archive is a ten-page typescript with annotations and corrections on the subject of capital punishment. It appears to be the text of a speech Squire gave on the subject, and in it he highlights the danger of condemning an innocent man. He proceeds to provide the details of a particular death penalty case that illustrated his concerns, writing, in part: "I thought for a good many years that it might be necessary to have capital punishment in order to deterr [sic] murder, but being connected with Sing Sing Prison and having had an opportunity of studying more than 200 men condemned to death and taking part in 138 electrocutions...I have come to the conclusion for some time past that the death penalty does not lessen murder. ... One of the importent [sic] factors in the conviction of Steilow was expert testimony and where expert testimony is received...I do not feel that too much weight should be given to such testimony unless it is corroborated by more exact facts. ... It may be well enough to send a man to prison on expert testimony for a period of years but no one who has stood by the side of...the rigid form of the person being electrocuted will believe that the extreme penalty of death should be imposed on such expert testimony."

Correspondence within the archive concerns legal cases, autopsies, and Squire's career with the New York Naval Reserves. Some of the legal letters concern worker's compensation or insurance claims. One of these from 1944 concerns an electrocution -- something with which Squire was all too familiar. He reviews the details of the case, his research on the subject, and concludes, "I personally autopsied 138 men who were legally electrocuted at Sing Sing Prison.... I have read the report by Dr. Brian Stookey and I agree with him in every respect...that the claimant in this case could not have been injured by 15,000 volts and a half milliampere of current which would have produced progressive muscular atrophy." There are likewise some travel receipts and medical receipts, as well as four photographs which depict Dr. Squire and his wife. A wonderful and interesting archive of an important medical figure in New York State.

Price: $850.00

See all items by ,